that was Fairly great
This deserves an 8 because it was nice. It was well done and thoughtful, creative and surprising. But none of these elements were TOO great. More time must be spent if you really want a ten. The scene with the hand futiley grabbing for the ice was especially nice. If the whole thing was done like that It would have been amazing. One more thing try to stay away from see-through characters. At least fill them in then turn down the alpha if you were actually going for the transparent look.